Direct vs Regular Mutual Funds: What Is Good for You?

When you invest in a mutual fund, you get two options: Direct Plan and Regular Plan.
The fund portfolio is the same, the fund manager is the same—but the cost and returns differ.

Understanding the difference helps you pick the right option for your investing style.

1. What Are Direct Mutual Funds?

A Direct Plan is when you invest directly with the mutual fund company (AMC) — without any agent, advisor, or broker.

Features:

  • No commission

  • Lower expense ratio

  • Higher returns (compared to Regular plans)

  • You need to select and manage funds on your own

Best for:

  • DIY (Do-It-Yourself) investors

  • People comfortable researching mutual funds

  • Investors doing long-term SIPs

  • Tech-savvy users using online AMC portals

2. What Are Regular Mutual Funds?

A Regular Plan involves investing through an intermediary like:

  • Broker

  • Distributor

  • Mutual fund agent

  • Online platforms

  • Banks

  • Financial advisors

They help you choose funds, handle paperwork, and manage investments—but they charge a commission, which is added to the expense ratio.

Features:

  • Higher expense ratio

  • Lower returns (vs Direct)

  • You get personalized support, guidance, and service

Best for:

  • Beginners

  • Busy professionals

  • People who need expert advice

  • Investors with little market knowledge

3. Key Differences Between Direct and Regular Mutual Funds

Feature Direct Plan Regular Plan
Expense Ratio Low High
Returns Higher Lower
Commission None Yes
Who Selects the Fund? You Advisor / Agent
Guidance Not available Available
NAV (Net Asset Value) Higher Lower
Convenience Medium High (because of advisor support)
Best For Experienced or self-managed investors Beginners, busy or unsure investors

4. Returns Comparison: Direct vs Regular

Direct plans usually deliver 0.5% to 1.5% higher returns annually compared to regular plans—due to lower expense ratios.

Example (Simple Illustration)

If two people invest ₹10 lakh for 15 years:

Plan Annual Returns Corpus After 15 Years
Direct 12% ₹54.19 lakh
Regular 11% ₹46.95 lakh

Difference: ₹7.24 lakh extra just by choosing Direct.

Over 20–25 years, the difference becomes even bigger.

5. Which Should You Choose?

Choose Direct Mutual Funds if:

  • You understand mutual funds

  • You can research on your own

  • You want maximum returns

  • You’re investing long term (SIP or lumpsum)

  • You’re comfortable using AMC websites or apps

Best For:
Experienced investors, DIY investors, long-term wealth creators.

Choose Regular Mutual Funds if:

  • You need guidance for fund selection

  • You want someone to manage or monitor your portfolio

  • You prefer convenience over saving money

  • You do not understand market cycles

  • You want help in portfolio rebalancing or tax planning

Best For:
Beginners, elderly investors, business owners, busy professionals.

6. Are Direct Plans Always Better?

Not always.

A Direct Plan gives higher returns, but if you choose the wrong fund, you may lose more than the commission you’re trying to save.

So:

  • If you’re confident—choose Direct.

  • If you’re unsure—choose Regular until you learn the basics.

Remember:
Proper fund selection > Low expense ratio.

7. How to Switch from Regular to Direct?

You can switch using:

  • AMC website/app

  • Through CAMS or KFintech

  • Offline form submission

Note:
Switching is considered redemption + fresh investment, so it may attract:

  • Exit load

  • Capital gains tax

Switch smartly after checking these factors.

8. Final Verdict: What Is Good for You?

Choose Direct Plan if:

  • You want higher long-term returns

  • You can manage investments independently

  • You’re comfortable doing research

Choose Regular Plan if:

  • You need expert support

  • You prefer convenience

  • You don’t understand fund selection yet

Leave a Comment